Jaime was born, a daughter of Jim and Cyndi Colman, in 1991. She grew up in Pennsylvania, where her family still resides. She married her husband, Matthew Eldred, in June 2019. They currently live in Washington with their male Chesapeake Bay Retriever, Gibson.

Jaime holds degrees from Houghton College in Houghton, New York, and the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies in Washington. She works on International Development and African Affairs for the federal government.

Outside of work, Jaime enjoys spending time outdoors, birding, reading, running, and yoga.